G&L
L-2000 Modding
Study A Study On Extended Pickup Configurations And Voicing last update: Jan 29, 2022 Copyright 2019-2022
by H. Gragger. All Rights Reserved. All
information provided herein is destined for
educational and D.I.Y. purposes only. Commercial
re-sale, distribution or usage of artwork without
explicit written permission of the author is
strictly prohibited. The original units with
their associated trade-names are subject to
the copyright of the individual copyright or
trademark owner. The Author is by no means
affiliated with any of those companies. References
to trade names are made for educational purposes
only. By reading the information provided here you
agree to the Terms
of
Use.
|
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
MAIN PAGE>MUSIC STUFF>L2000 Index Measuring MFD Pickup Specs Nomenclature: New Switching Functions Demand A New Name For The Switches Evaluation: Why Do Players Consistently Revert To Passive Mode? Exploring Existing Groundwork And Setting New Goals Circuitry Overview Making The Changes Voicing Hands-On Experience Active Noise Reduction For Single Coil Mode Passive Noise Reduction References And Recommended Reading Sound Samples Update History
Back To Index Measuring MFD Pickup Specs
Used measurement equipment: Caveat:
Back To Index Nomenclature: New Switching Functions Demand A New Name For The Switches With the advent of
complex coil interconnection circuitry, some
nomenclature commonly used within this context has
to be revised to describe phenomena previously non
existent. If those terms are not made clear, it is impossible to understand the following elaborations. For example, in a basic two pickup system consisting oft two single coils, one at the neck and one at the bridge, one may find a 3-position selector switch, one for neck, one for both and one for bridge position. Now this may be classically called pickup selector switch, which, since it has no secondary function, also serves as source selector switch.
In the case of the
modded L-2000, the previous pickup selector
switch (the one closest to the neck) loses its
direct coil cluster fixation
and becomes a source selector switch.
The center switch (series/parallel)
maintains its original functionality, but complex
coil interconnection, beyond fixation to a cluster
of adjacent coils, is transferred to a newly
introduced three-way switch, best called parallel
pair selector. In this case, any pair
of coils, possibly spreading over non adjacent coil
clusters, may be selected (such as inner pair
or outer pair), which if source selector is
in both mode will be a humbucking (parallel)
pair, but in solo (neck or bridge mode) a single
coil. See the
reference chart later on. For clarity, a distinction has been made between coils belonging to one physical cluster of adjacent coils (hereafter native mode) and two physical units (hereafter cross mode). According to the
previous differentiation between performance
and recording switching schemes the scheme
presented in the following is positioned in-between.
It is experimental and work in progress. Ideally,
there should be a “P”, a “J” and a “S” position and
little more. The widely used
nomenclature „single inner“ resp. „single outer“ is
a misnomer, since it indicates single coils, but it
is actually a hum canceling pair (for both
mode at least).
It is replaced by the terms inner pair and outer pair, referring to the physical arrangement of 2+2 coils at the neck resp. bridge side. "Inner" and "outer" makes only sense in reference to this arrangement. Nevertheless, true single coil operation for all four coils is possible, it comes into the bargain. Refer to the pickup selection chart for more information. Evaluation: Why Do Players Consistently Revert To Passive Mode?
Some users of the L-2000
insist on using it passive, with volume and tone
pots dimmed. Why? We want to understand this,
because there may be things we can optimise into
the bargain. This also builds some foundation
for any alleged voicing later on.
Some aside to technical explanation is inevitable. Every pickup basically is a resonant R-L-C circuit (winding resistance, inductance and winding capacity), which forms a higher order resonant low pass. Guitar Letters explains this well.Happily, some small capacitors and resistors before the buffer can tame any of those things and thus introduce all of the merits of passive mode without its drawbacks. It so happens the L-2000 already has a 1nF cap in parallel by definition (this is the one soldered onto the bass pot). This, to my taste, is too hefty. See later in the section on voicing.Our extended switching circuitry offers some unassigned positions for that into the bargain. Since this procedure is really that easy and cheap, it makes me wonder if the ones who devised the circuitry did only have their sales numbers in mind, saving caps worth cents... It brings more money to sell another instrument rather than have just one that does all you want... Back To Index Evaluation: OMG Mode, More Boosts That Are None And Boosts That Chase Their Own Tail In 1982 Leo Fender filed a patent
(US.-Pat. 4,319,510) for splitting humbuckers that do
not have all leads accessible, also known as three
wire humbuckers.
This is in fact astonishingly simple. As different to shorting out a coil entirely, a capacitor shunts frequencies out. Choosing the capacitor´s size wisely, 50 Hertz hum cancellation remains intact. However, higher frequency hum (such as from switching electronic appliances) will not cancel. Making the capacity smaller will work better, but let increasing amounts of low frequency content through.On the L-2000 basses, Leo was probably trying to achieve a pseudo single coil sound, which is less boomy, and in the verge of trying different caps found the bass boost attractive. How the term OMG came about is unknown, since this is recent social platform lingo. By shorting some of the treble content out, bass content appears louder. Although just cutting and not boosting, this mode was called „bass boost“. All is relative. Unfortunately, together with the fixed 1nF voicing cap, this mode sounds pretty dark. Maybe interesting for some retro sounds, but not for contemporary sounds. Again this is no real coil splitting, it is a humbucker wired pseudo single coil. There is no coil shorted out with a hard wire bridge. OMG mode lead to many complaints by musicians, because hum suppression is, like in all single coil circuits, inferior. Moreover, Leo could have at least the center position (both) humbucking, which was recognized by the DIY community[1], but never cured by the company. Conversely, they decided to drop OMG entirely on later modes, such as in my specimen of the bass. My personal opinion is that the series wired pickups are powerful enough the way they are - without "boost", and that it is somewhat awkward to generate a bass overload first and then use treble boost to remedy that. The cat bites its own tail. When working with new modes it became obvious that the volume drop between serial and all other modes was a nuisance, requiring a permanent re-adjustment of the volume pot. The previous owner had made a feature out of this flaw by calling it the „rock switch“ - volume boost. Hmm. Rather make a small, adjustment on the volume pot if needed.I found the idea great to equalize the volume levels by adding a series resistor where normally the wire bridge between yellow and black goes. Extensive listening tests in both active and passive mode and also some PC simulation did not indicate any change in tone. Of course, OMG does not harmonize with that, but this was deemed questionable anyway as elaborated above. There is no need for pseudo humbucking if real coilsplitting is at hand. However, by bypassing the dropping resistors with a cap, some partial "boost" of high frequencies can be achieved. Again, this is no boost, but treble content gets less suppressed. Why making half hearted attempts towards single coil sound when a brighter sound can be achieved another way while maintaining full hum canceling functionality? Exploring Existing Groundwork And Setting New Goals By far the most of the mod tips I could find are limited to the installation of a three-position (on-on-on) switch, selecting between serial, parallel, and one single coil combination, and possibly a push-pull pot for extra switching, which basically replaces the existing two-position serial/parallel switch. All the those attempts to maintain the original possibilities (serial, parallel) plus at least two cross-connections (inner/outer pair) without inviting other penalties, failed to my knowledge. There is a limited amount of switching possibilities that manipulate the „hot“ side of the pickups, and even more limited for the „ground“ side, since G&L have decided early to connect a screening ground plate to one of the coils (green wire). Drilling some holes for extra switches or the like was not an option, being commonly associated with a loss in resale value. A guy named Femto has devised a switching method using the stock serial/parallel switch plus an extra on-on-on switch, which would have to take the active/passive switch location (this one moving to the switch of a push-pull pot), yet functionally being very similar to the method devised by me. Femto manipulated the ground sides of the coils, which, although this appeared to work for him noise-wise, might invite trouble due to the ground plane floating, that is mounted to the bottom side of each physical unit. It is likely that people were reluctant to adopt his method because of this fact. However, combining both high side and low side switching turned out to work flawless with a compatible switch layout.
The goals for modification thus were set to be:
In a nutshell: the newly devised switching scheme keeps the original serial/parallel switch, except that the range of available parallel modes has been expanded, determined by the setting of the parallel pair selector configuration switch. Dependent on the setting of the source selector switch, all four individual coils can be addressed in true single coil mode too.The parallel pair selector switch physically resides in the space, that was previously occupied by the active/passive switch, whose functionality moved onto a push-pull switch linked to the volume pot knob. Note: treble boost mode has been dropped as mentioned earlier. When both is selected on the source selection switch, those positions are hum canceling. Since the coils are arranged N/S - N/S starting from the neck, the cross-mode arrangements xS - Nx (inner pair) and Nx-xS (outer pair) are hum canceling as well as the native N/S arrangements. Note: In solo mode (e.g. neck only), out of the selected pair, although both coils are active, only one will contribute to the output signal - the one residing in the source selected (neck in the example), hence a true single coil. This one is subject to hum as all single coils are. Determining which one out of the two adjacent coils is currently active is slightly awkward and is not always in direct relation to the switches´ lever position due to the fact that one has been eliminated out of a cross-pair. Logic has been optimized in so far that the lever points towards the inside of the guitar body in inside pair mode and towards the outside in outside pair mode. Thus, only if bridge solo is selected, the parallel pair switches´ lever points to the correct single coil, but this is reversed for neck. This is inevitable and a small problem. Back To Index Making The Changes
Voicing Now the switching stuff has all been sussed, a whole new can of worms is torn open – voicing[5]. Browsing through the settings invariably involves a change in perception of treble, mid and bass content, some subtle, some heavy. A minimalistic guitar setup will be equipped with a treble control, which, as we saw earlier, can tame the resonance peak and cut some high. The second resonance that occurs when the pot is at zero (caused by the treble cap), is usually too extreme to be useful. So those positions remain essentially raw and untreated sonically. Lester Polfus, better known as Les Paul, was confronted with exactly the same problem back in the seventies with his Les Paul Recording Guitar, and he solved it by providing a rotary switch with an array of caps, not different to the C-switch devices available today. He aptly called his guitar recording, since, in a performance situation, few would have been able to cope with all those knobs and switches. These days, things head towards performance selector switches (such as in those fancy aftermarket 5-way Strat switches), which select between “sounds” consisting of useful coil presets and potentially voicings. This means a deliberate step backwards from Les Paul´s idea for the sake of simplicity and performance, but he wanted it all. Despite thousands of schemes available on the internet, rarely anybody exploits the whole potential of tone shaping those positions. A 1nF cap (stock) is already active for all positions, which to my personal taste was too much. It was replaced by a 680 pF Styroflex cap. This made the series signal even more pristine, alleviating the need for an active treble boost even more. First listening tests on the untreated parallel modes and particularly the single coil modes revealed a pretty trebly, sterile tone, reminding of early Stanley Clarke recordings. A test jig was put together quickly, nothing different than what is known as the commercial C-switch or tonestyler (a rotary switch with a rake of small caps) and small caps in the nF range (around 2.2nF) were found for each position that brought the resonant frequency down to an pleasing value before tone was becoming honky. Naturally, single can take more capacity than parallel, but due to the lack of unoccupied switching positions a compromise value of 2.2 nF was chosen for all non-series positions. Tone gets much more mellow by this, without sounding honky or bassy. The acute reader will have noticed, that this demands another switching element in the series/parallel switch, which is non existent unfortunately, but some crafty solution has been found, remaining my ace card for the moment. Any excessive resonance peak (“Q”), perceived as stinging quality, can further be tamed by dialing the treble pot down just a hair, long before the treble cutting action itself comes into play, so individual Q-shaping resistors were equally abandoned due to the lack of switching positions. "Passive tone" despite buffering was re-contemplated. A typical guitar cord may exhibit 100pF/m capacity, a 6m cable will thus easily have 600 pF. Together with the built-in load 1 nF capacity this is a fairly hefty load for a passive system - too big for my taste as mentioned, but some seem to like it. Hands-On Experience With all this extra
switching, you can always leave the parallel
pairs selector in center position, in which case
the bass behaves exactly like stock, leaving
aside volume equalization and voicing. It
certainly looks stock. Flipping the parallel
pairs selector into another position,
you´ll have powerful presets ready at the flip
of a switch.
All of those features accessible with the new circuit have their merit, but time will tell if the increase of switching options or -methods itself is a blessing or a curse. Back To Index Active Noise Reduction For Single Coil Mode After some playing, the single coil modes do not sound particularly attractive or reminiscent of other basses´ sounds*, but they are different and interesting and may as well be used. Unfortunately they are prone to hum. Maybe, due to the powerful nature of the pickups, more than others. I tried to do something about this and made up a large area aircoil (not unlike the Suhr silent coil) to passively cancel out hum frequencies. * Maybe I expected to have a Precision sound or a J-Bass sound at hand, and while it surely crosses into that territory (like any similarly built pickup in that position will...) I found there is no such a thing like THE XY sound. There are several web sites that try to carve this out and they had to admit that they failed, because over the years so many models with different body and neck woods resp. shapes and surely differently wound pickups had been made. This can´t be generalized.
Back To Index Passive Noise Reduction Now that all
active methods to eliminate hum failed, I find myself
back at the roots. While it is true that screening
won´t help against magnetic interference, it will
certainly help against electrostatic
interference. And true, some of what I hear,
sounds like a harmonic of mains (transformer
originated) frequency, without the fundamental.
Back To IndexI opened the pickup cavities - and they are bare wood. Agreed, the guitar was never intended to be used with single coils, but even in humbucking modes it appeared vulnerable to higher frequent noises. To cancel those the "aperture" of the two coils is too big. People report that with screening they made even humbuckers quieter. I have plenty of copper foil at home, but there is no space in those cavities. So I bought a small bottle of Humbrella screening paint invented by a German guy and allegedly preferred by luthiers. This does not consume any noteworthy space. Three layers with drying time in between is recommended. With a small brush I even poked a little into the tunnels that go from the electronics compartment to the pickup cavities. The wires should be screened too. (See my hints further down on working with the paint)
After assembly, I inserted a small strip of copper foil in a crevice right beside the pickups to contact the paint and measured some 50 Ohms against ground. This is absolutely perfect.
As expected, hum did not go down, but its higher frequent components did. The effect is subtle, but noticeable. Let me know if any of this is useful or appeals to you. References And Recommended Reading Credits: Many threads on modification of the L-2000 have been sieved through, notably written by a guy named DavePlaysBass in talkbass guitar forum and BassesByLeo forum (several threads), by Femto and Ken Baker, who maintains BassesByLeo, all of whom I feel deeply indepted to. Credits also go to Ulf Schaedla in Germany, probably the best source of information on pickups and voicing currently available. [1] G&L L2K Wiring Mods Rev 4.1, 27-Dec-2117, by DavePlaysBass@hotmail.com, p.2 Fixing Bad Designs: Barrel-Style Output Jacks - Hanff Guitar Repair [2] Jack Replacement: (how to re-fit a new barrel jack), by Ken Baker from BassesByLeo [3] Jack Replacement: (how to replace a barrel jack by a conventional jack), by BluesBassPlayer on BassesByLeo forum [4] G&L Preamp Rev 2.2, 12/28/2017, by DavePlaysBass@hotmail.com [5] Guitar-Letters: a wealth of information on pickups and voicing (in German language), by Ulf Schaedla Back To Index Sound Samples The subsequent recordings have been done using the following setup and no further processing:
Back To Index Update History
MAIN PAGE>MUSIC STUFF>L2000 |
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
MAIN PAGE | MUSIC STUFF | IMPRESSUM (c) 2019-2022 AQUATAUR Musik & Elektronik |